Controlling Construction Cost Overruns: Practical Strategies for Australian Projects

Introduction

Cost overruns in the Australian construction industry are not just a statistic — they are a serious challenge, costing billions of dollars a year. If you’re in real estate development or construction management, you know that these budget overruns can significantly impact project viability and profitability.

In this article, I share with you my insights from 24 years of industry experience on why construction projects go over budget and, more importantly, what strategies have worked to keep your projects on track financially. We’ll take a look at alarming industry statistics, identify the main causes of budget overruns and share five practical approaches that have helped our clients successfully control costs.

At Bidkon, we’ve worked on more than 500 projects ranging in size from $2 million to $100 million, always focusing on cost efficiency and value. Our experience on residential, commercial, infrastructure and public projects has given us a unique insight into effective cost management techniques that work in the Australian market.

As a registered and accredited Quantity Surveyor with the Victorian Building Authority and a member of the Australian Institute of Quantity Surveyors, I have seen how professional cost management can transform project outcomes. Let’s take a closer look at why cost overruns occur and what you can do about them.

What You’ll Learn in This Article

• The current state of cost overruns in Australian construction projects
• Eight key factors that cause budgets to blow out
• Five practical strategies to keep your projects financially on track
• How early intervention can save millions in project costs
• Why professional quantity surveying expertise delivers strong ROI

The Alarming Reality of Construction Cost Overruns in Australia

The statistics on cost overruns in Australian construction projects paint a concerning picture that requires the immediate attention of our industry. According to the Australian Bureau of Statistics, about 23% of construction projects experience cost overruns. For large infrastructure projects, the numbers are even more alarming—74% end up over-time and over-budget (Source).

According to research by the Grattan Institute, over the past 15 years, Australian governments have spent $28 billion more on transport infrastructure than initially budgeted, with cost overruns amounting to nearly a quarter (24%) of total project budgets [source]. What’s striking is that 90% of Australia’s cost overrun problem comes from just 17% of projects—those that exceed their promised costs by more than 50% [source]. This suggests that while most projects maintain reasonable cost control, when things go wrong, they can go catastrophically wrong.

For transport infrastructure projects completed since 2001, the Grattan Institute revealed an average cost overrun of 21% [source]. The situation worsens for larger projects, with those exceeding $1 billion having nearly half experience cost overruns, averaging 30% above their initial estimates [source].

With Australia’s construction pipeline reaching a record $224 billion as of August 2023, the potential for widespread financial strain without effective cost control measures is significant [source]. A 2019 KPMG study revealed that only 31% of construction projects completed within the previous three years came within 10% of their original budget [source].

Main Causes of Construction Cost Overruns

Understanding the root causes of cost overruns is critical to developing effective prevention strategies. Based on industry research and our experience at Bidkon, these factors are the main causes:

1. Poor Planning and Estimation

Inaccurate project planning lays the foundation for financial difficulties later on. Many cases of cost overruns begin with inadequate budgeting and inaccurate cost estimates, often based on assumptions rather than actual project data. According to the Grattan Institute, projects with cost estimates that are announced too early have significantly larger overruns – on average 35% more than projects whose costs were announced at or after commitment.

The lack of a detailed cost breakdown can lead to significant underestimates of key elements such as labor, material and equipment costs. Insufficient due diligence at the pre-construction stage, including incomplete feasibility studies and inadequate pricing in Bills of Quantities (BOQs), can lead to significant gaps between estimated and actual costs.

It is also important to recognize the role of psychological factors. A tendency towards optimism or even a strategic underestimation of costs in order to secure project approval can contribute significantly to these initial inaccuracies.

2. Escalation of material prices

Material costs make up a significant part of the construction budget, and price fluctuations can quickly derail financial planning. According to industry studies, material price escalation is responsible for 60% of cost overruns in construction projects [source]. This challenge has become particularly acute in recent years due to disruptions in the global supply chain and inflationary pressures.

According to recent data from the Australian Bureau of Statistics, construction prices have risen by 0.4% in the last quarter and 4.3% in the last twelve months, largely due to increased material costs [source]. These fluctuations in construction material costs are often cited as the main reason for budget overruns.

3. Increase in Scope and Design Changes

Uncontrolled changes and the addition of new tasks or features after work has begun can quickly drive up project costs. Even seemingly minor changes can require additional time, materials and labor pushing projects beyond its original financial limits.

According to industry studies, 32% of cost overruns are due to design creep [source]. While some degree of design creep is inevitable, implementing strict change management protocols minimizes the financial impact of these changes. Often these changes are due to inadequate initial planning, resulting in frequent design revisions and material adjustments throughout the project lifecycle.

4. Time Delays

Construction delays result in numerous costs, including increased overhead expenses, potential compensation claims and resource allocation issues. Time delays contribute to 36% of cost overruns [source]. The relationship between time and cost requires integrated management of both factors throughout the project lifecycle.

Every day a project is delayed incurs additional costs for extra labor, equipment rental and material storage. Inefficient planning can lead to interruptions in the workflow and a waste of resources. External factors such as unexpected bad weather or unforeseen problems on the construction site can lead to unforeseen work interruptions and increased costs.

5. Contractual Disputes

Disagreements between project stakeholders regarding contract interpretation, deliverables or responsibilities lead to delays and additional costs. These disputes contribute to 40% of project cost overruns [source]. Clear contract documentation and experienced contract administration are important safeguards against this risk.

6. Premature Project Announcements

The Grattan Institute has highlighted an interesting political dimension to cost overruns: premature project announcements, especially before elections, contribute significantly to budget overruns. Although only 32% of projects were announced early, these projects accounted for 74% of the total value of cost overruns [source]. This suggests that politically motivated timing often precedes proper cost analysis and planning.

7. Inadequate Risk Management

Failure to proactively identify potential risks and develop mitigation strategies is a common precursor to budget overruns. The lack of sufficient reserves for unexpected expenses makes projects financially vulnerable. A lack of thorough risk assessment and effective data management can contribute to unforeseen cost escalations.

8. Poor Project Management and Communication

Inefficient project management practices can directly lead to cost overruns and project delays. Poor communication between team members, stakeholders and subcontractors can lead to misunderstandings, errors and rework, all of which have financial implications. A lack of clear collaboration between the parties involved can hinder problem solving and contribute to budget issues. Unclear decision-making authority within project management structures can exacerbate these challenges.

Five Practical Strategies to Avoid Cost Overruns

At Bidkon, we use comprehensive cost management strategies to help our clients avoid budget blowouts. Based on our experience and industry best practices, here are five proven approaches:

1. Comprehensive Planning Before Construction Begins

Thorough planning before construction begins is perhaps the most effective way to control costs. This includes:

• Detailed site surveys to identify potential challenges early on
• Comprehensive feasibility studies that consider multiple scenarios
• Stakeholder engagement to identify and proactively address concerns
• Realistic time planning that allows for potential delays
• Integration of sustainability aspects in the planning stage

Projects with well-documented plans are significantly more likely to stay on budget. During the planning phase, you should conduct thorough research and use industry benchmarks and historical data from similar projects to obtain accurate cost estimates.

At Bidkon, our attention to detail ensures thorough, precise, and complete results at this critical stage. We have seen time and time again that the investment in planning pays off by avoiding costs later in the project.

2. Robust Contingency Planning and Risk Management

As unforeseen circumstances in construction cannot be ruled out, establishing a robust contingency fund is essential. Effective contingency planning requires:

• Identification and quantification of specific project risks
• Allocation of adequate contingency funds based on the risk assessment
• Regular review and adjustment of contingency amounts as risks evolve
• Clear protocols for accessing and approving contingency funds
• Clear separation between contingencies and changes to the scope of the project

Industry standards suggest that a typical contingency budget should be between 5-10% of the total budget for standard projects, while high-risk or complex projects may require 10-20% [source]. This dedicated reserve can help to absorb costs associated with issues such as bad weather, unforeseen site conditions or fluctuations in material prices.

At Bidkon, each project we apply these risk management principles to protect the client’s interests. We have found that strategic contingency planning provides the necessary financial flexibility without encouraging unnecessary expenditure.

3. Early Involvement of Quantity Surveying Expertise

The timing of involvement in cost management has a critical impact on its effectiveness. Early involvement enables:

• Cost-focused design development from the start of the project
• Value engineering opportunities before the design is finalized
• Identification of potential cost risks when mitigation is still possible
• Development of procurement strategies that optimize value
• Establishing robust cost monitoring systems from the outset

Early cost estimates are critical to align design intentions with realistic budget constraints from the outset. Regular budget checks during the design and pre-construction phase allow for timely adjustments, turnarounds or even temporary pauses to ensure the project remains financially viable.

Our experience at Bidkon has shown that changes made in the planning phase can cost 1/10 of what they would cost during the construction phase. By engaging our services early on, you can find cost-effective alternatives and solutions before they impact the budget. By involving Bidkon early on, our clients have saved millions as we have identified cost-effective design alternatives that maintain quality while reducing costs.

4. Robust Change Management Protocols

Change is inevitable in construction projects, but its financial impact can be controlled by:

• Clear documentation of all change requests
• Rigorous assessment of cost impact prior to approval
• Streamlined approval processes with appropriate authorization levels
• Comprehensive communication of changes to all stakeholders
• Regular reconciliation of approved changes with the original budget

Implementing a formal change request process is essential to thoroughly evaluate how proposed changes will impact project costs before they are approved. Educating all stakeholders about the established budget limits and the potential financial risks associated with additional work is critical to maintaining cost discipline.

A systematic review and approval process for all change orders should be strictly enforced. Keeping detailed records of each change, including its justification, associated costs and impact on the project schedule, ensures transparency and accountability.

These protocols create accountability and transparency around project changes and prevent the incremental expansion of project scope that often leads to cost overruns.

5. Continuous Cost Monitoring and Control

Establishing a comprehensive cost control system with regular financial reporting, real-time cost tracking and performance analysis against the baseline budget is essential for avoiding cost overruns. Regular monitoring allows project teams to identify variances early and take corrective action before minor issues become major problems.

Studies show that projects with robust monitoring systems experience fewer and less serious cost overruns. At Bidkon, we provide our clients with comprehensive monthly financial reports that compare actual spend against budget and enable proactive management of potential overruns.

This approach includes:

• Regular formal cost reviews and reports
• Real-time tracking of spend against budgeted amounts
• Early identification and mitigation of potential cost variances
• Value engineering assessments throughout the project
• Proactive procurement and material management
• Documentation of lessons learned for future cost planning

Conclusion: The Value of Expertise

Let’s be clear: cost overruns aren’t inevitable. With proper planning, accurate estimation, effective monitoring, and expert guidance, your projects can be delivered on budget, on time, and to specification.

The strategies outlined in this article- comprehensive pre-construction planning, robust contingency planning, early engagement of quantity surveying expertise, change management protocols, and continuous cost monitoring provide a roadmap for controlling construction costs. Each approach addresses specific risk factors that commonly lead to budget blowouts.

At Bidkon, we specialize in quantity surveying and cost estimating to help our clients overcome these challenges. We understand that successful project delivery must balance limited resources, tight schedules and budget constraints while ensuring quality and sustainability.

I would encourage you to consider how your next project could benefit from the early involvement of quantity surveying experts. The investment in professional cost management typically represents only a fraction of the potential savings from avoided overruns. By applying these proven strategies, you will be better equipped for success in Australia’s increasingly complex construction environment.

References:

https://conplant.com.au/news/construction-project-management-tips/

https://grattan.edu.au/report/cost-overruns-in-transport-infrastructure/

https://grattan.edu.au/wp-content/uploads/2016/10/878-Cost-overruns-on-transport-infrastructure.pdf

https://grattan.edu.au/wp-content/uploads/2020/11/The-Rise-of-Megaprojects-Grattan-Report.pdf

https://grattan.edu.au/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/ATRF2016-cost-overruns-final-submission_updated.pdf

https://www.abs.gov.au/statistics/industry/building-and-construction/building-activity-australia

https://assets.kpmg/content/dam/kpmg/xx/pdf/2019/04/global-construction-survey-2019.pdf

https://www.wunderbuild.com/blog/managing-construction-projects-in-australia-best-practices/

https://portal.engineersaustralia.org.au/event/2023/07/understanding-the-causes-of-cost-overruns-and-practical-solutions-49496

https://blog.iseekplant.com.au/blog/seven-tips-to-avoid-construction-cost-overrun

https://www.abs.gov.au/statistics/economy/price-indexes-and-inflation/producer-price-indexes-australia/latest-release

https://www.mastt.com/blogs/cost-overruns-construction-project-management

https://www.infrastructureaustralia.gov.au/sites/default/files/2021-10/A%20National%20Study%20of%20Infrastructure%20Risk.pdf

https://www.cis.org.au/publication/bungles-blowouts-and-boondoggles-why-australias-infrastructure-projects-cost-more-than-they-should/

https://portal.engineersaustralia.org.au/news/managing-cost-overruns-public-infrastructure

https://measuremanage.com.au/blog/how-quantity-surveyors-protect-clients-from-budget-overruns/

https://www.wunderbuild.com/blog/managing-construction-projects-in-australia-best-practices/